Leading a Team You Didn't Hire
Almost nobody in banking gets to build a team from nothing. A new head of sector coverage in London, or a new country head in Paris, walks onto a floor that somebody else hired and promoted and is expected to produce results with it by the following bonus round.
Most of what gets written about leadership assumes the opposite. Michael Watkins, the IMD professor behind The First 90 Days, made the point in Harvard Business Review a decade ago: the well-known models of team building start with the leader choosing the members, and that is rarely the job on offer. The job on offer is somebody else’s team, with its loyalties, its idiosyncrasies and its history already in place.
If you’ve taken over a team recently, or you’re about to appoint someone who will, a few things are worth knowing before the first day.
What the research says
DDI’s 2021 Leadership Transitions Report found that 35% of executives promoted from within were judged to have failed in the role, rising to 47% for those hired from outside. Two cautions come with that. The figures rest on the perceptions of HR leaders, as DDI itself points out, and they cover executives in general, so they aren’t a measure of banking. Even so, close to half is a hard number to ignore for the external hire, who is the person a search firm is paid to find.
Nobody has published the equivalent number for a new head of coverage. DDI’s work does suggest where the trouble starts, and it is mostly after the appointment rather than before it. New leaders tend to keep their difficulties to themselves, and the organisations that appointed them offer little structured support once the announcement has gone out. Only 35% of senior executives in DDI’s research received any coaching during their transition, and only 21% were given a formal mentor. Choosing the right person is half the job. The other half is what happens in their first year.
What your team is doing while you settle in
You’ll probably think of your first quarter as a period of assessment. Your team will be assessing you too, and they will have started earlier.
By the time your appointment is announced, the people on the desk have already found out what they can. They’ve rung former colleagues. They know whether you brought people across at your last firm and how those who were already there got on afterwards. A change of leadership is also one of the clearer signs to the rest of the market that a team might be open to an approach, so your strongest VP may well be hearing from other firms in the same few weeks.
We saw this last year with an MD we helped bring into a sector team. Almost all of their interviews were with senior bankers at the firm. They met very few of the VPs and associates they would be leading, including the juniors who would later sit on their 360 reviews. So the team’s first real look at their new MD came on day one, and so did the MD’s first real look at the team. It made for a slower start than it needed to be. They are performing well now, and the team has adapted quickly to their way of working, but a couple of conversations with the juniors during the process would have got everyone there sooner. It's also good for buy-in and makes everyone feel part of the decision to hire them even if some views have more weight than others.
Your first conversations matter more than your first strategy presentation. The good people will want early answers on where they stand and whether someone new is about to be parachuted in over them.
The temptation to bring your own people
Most senior hires arrive with a short list of former colleagues they’d like to bring across. Sometimes that was part of the deal from the start, and when a team is being rebuilt, it can be the right call.
The cost is less obvious. Every import tells the inherited team something about its prospects, and the director who was next in line feels the new arrivals more than most. Bring in two trusted colleagues in your first six months and you may end up with a team that is loyal to you and knows the clients less well than the one you inherited.
The opposite mistake is just as common. Some new heads change nothing for a year because they don’t want to look ruthless, and they carry a weak number two long after everyone on the desk has noticed. In our experience, decisions about people are the ones that get put off longest.
Who was good, and who was good for your predecessor
An inherited team comes with inherited reputations. The previous head had favourites, and the year-end rankings reflect that as much as they reflect ability. The associate rated in the middle of the pack may have done the work on the three deals that closed. The star may have been a star because they were handed the best clients.
Watkins’ advice is to assess each person afresh against what the business needs next, rather than against how they’ve been described. That is hard to do from the inside, because you have no baseline. You can see how your director compares with the other directors on the floor, but not how they compare with their counterparts at other banks.
Knowing the peer group across the market changes that. It tells you whether you have a strong bench that needs backing or an average one that needs changing. Without it, you’re relying on the judgement of the person you replaced.
When changing the team is the right answer
Keeping everyone isn’t always right either. Some teams were built for a market that has gone, and some new heads are appointed because the old team wasn’t working. In those cases moving slowly is the unkind option, both for the people who will eventually be asked to leave and for the ones waiting to see what happens.
The reason for the change is what people will judge. Replacing a director because you know the market has better ones is defensible. Doing it to make room for someone from your last bank is harder to justify, and the team will know which it was.
Before the first day
The transitions that go well tend to start before the start date. Use the weeks between signing and starting to learn who is on the team and who is at risk of leaving, and to form a view of who in the wider market would be worth knowing if a seat came open. Some of those views won’t survive your first month, which is to be expected.
If you’re the one making the appointment, you can help. Firms put months of work and a large fee into appointing a team head, and the briefing on the team that person is inheriting deserves some of the same care. A short, honest account of the team, set against the market it competes in, costs very little and may be the most useful thing they read before they start.
Sources
- DDI, Leadership Transitions Report 2021 (Global Leadership Forecast series), as summarised in Matt Paese, "Private Struggle: Why Executive Transitions Continue to Fail", May 2021
- Michael D. Watkins, "Leading the Team You Inherit", Harvard Business Review, June 2016

